East Bay Panel Update - Director Liability

You are here

Two weeks ago, we met with a great group of ECHO members at our East Bay Resource Panel. We were gathered to talk about the recent Parth case and how it affects the personal liability of HOA directors. Ann Marquis-Fisher, chair of the Panel and president of her HOA, invited attorney Mark Wleklinski to speak about the case, and David Stompe to discuss the insurance implications.

Here’s a not-so-brief summary of what we learned (it’s long because it’s important!):

Why You Need to Know Your Documents

Erna Parth was a director on the board of Palm Springs Villas II HOA. Her HOA sued her for decisions that she made while on the board, saying that she had breached her fiduciary duty. Ms. Parth, however, claimed that she should be immune from liability because of the “business judgement rule” and “judicial deference.” Also, the association’s governing documents contained language protecting director decisions.

Both the Business Judgment Rule and the principle of Judicial Deference help to protect board members from personal liability, even when they make bad decisions. So what happened here?

To understand, you need to know something about both terms.

Business Judgment and Judicial Deference

Business Judgement Rule. This rule says that Directors are not personally liable for decisions that result in damage or loss to others, provided their decisions were made in good faith, in a manner which the directors believe to be in the best interests of the corporation, and with such care, including reasonable inquiry, as an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would use under similar circumstances.

In other words, you can’t be personally sued if you put your community first, did your homework, and used common sense.

Judicial Deference. Also called the “business judgment doctrine,” this principle means the courts will defer to business decisions of a board even if a reasonable person would have acted differently. The courts will also assume that directors’ decision are based on sound business judgment. In both circumstances, the suing owner must prove that an association’s decisions do not deserve this deference.

In other words: The courts are going to assume that the association made a reasonable choice, unless the homeowner can prove a specific set of facts.

The Parth Case

But back to Erna Parth. Ms. Parth, claiming to operate with the authority of the board, made a string of questionable decisions. Here are a few:

  • Roofing repairs. Without consulting the board, Ms. Parth hired an unlicensed contractor to make roofing repairs. The board ultimately hired the roofer, but did not see many of the checks (signed only by Ms. Parth) paid to the roofer. The work was later determined to be both overpriced and deficient.
  • Repaving projects and loans. In order to fund a paving project, Ms. Parth signed for loans totaling more than $1.5 million without the approval of the membership as required by the governing documents.
  • Landscaping. Ms. Parth and other board members approved a 5-year landscaping contract in violation of their governing documents.
  • Termination of management. In spite the board’s decision to table the discussion of terminating their management company, Ms. Parth hired a new management company.
  • Security contract. Ms. Parth entered into a security contract on behalf of the association but without approval from the board. The board’s refusal to ratify or pay for this contract ultimately lead to a lawsuit from the security company.

You can visit this site to read the complete details of this case, Palm Springs Villa II HOA vs. Erna Parth.

What Went Wrong?

If bad decisions are protected by law, why weren’t these decisions protected? The court held that:

When courts say that they will not interfere in matters of business judgment, it is presupposed that judgment—reasonable diligence—has in fact been exercised. A director cannot close his eyes to what is going on about him in the conduct of the business of the corporation and have it said that he is exercising business judgment.

In other words, a director must be “reasonably diligent” before the court will apply the business judgment rule or judicial deference. The court also held that language in the governing documents protecting board decisions is subject to the same limits.

Limits on Board Protections

We’re going to assume that ECHO Members are not like Erna Parth. But what does this case mean for you? It means that a board member must show the court that they deserve the protections of the “Business Judgment Rule” and “Judicial Deference.”

You cannot assume that you are protected.

Here are two areas where you need to be particularly careful:

You must know your governing documents. Decisions of the board, even spectacularly bad ones, are usually protected by the Business Judgment Rule. But if those decisions violate the governing documents, the Rule may not apply.

You must investigate and decide. If the board doesn’t investigate a problem, use qualified experts, and fails to make a repair decision, their inaction does not receive judicial deference. In other words, only an investigation and decision qualifies for judicial deference, even if the decision is to do nothing.

A Note about Insurance

Most associations carry Directors & Officers insurance to provide protection against losses (including attorneys’ fees) that result from wrongdoing or negligence. David Stompe highlighted three important points:

  • Always tender to insurance. Insurance companies often deny claims that are not submitted in a timely fashion. If know about a potential claim, it’s important to submit it to insurance promptly.
  • Check your coverage. This may seem obvious, but coverage should be extensive, and should include claims for libel or slander (or other defamation), discrimination, and attorneys’ fees.
  • Check your exclusions. Avoid policies that contain an “insured vs. insured” exclusion.

If you are an ECHO member living in the East Bay and would like to attend these round-table discussions, please check the schedule in the ECHO Journal or online. We’d love to have you! Have a question about our Regional Panels? You can reach us here.

 

Blog Category: 

Comments

Very well written article. It will be helpful to everyone who employee it, including me. Keep up the good work.

Escorts Near Le Meridien Hotel

http://www.roshnikhanna.in/hotels/escorts-services-near-courtyard-by-marriott-hotel/

My Name Is Priya Singh. I Am An Independent Mumbai Escort Girl. I Run My Own Mumbai Escorts In Andheri West. You Can Enjoy To My Private Parts At Your Own Place. Being A Professional Escort Girl I Have Seven Years’ Experience Of Mumbai Escorts. Hence I Understand And Feel The Real Needs And Requirement Of My Each Client. According The Convenience You Can Avail My VIP Escort Service At Your Home Or In Hotel Also. To Book My VIP Mumbai Escort Service Call +91 9987215552.       
Visit  -http://www.escortagencyinmumbai.com/
Visit The Links Below And Have A Look At My Various Mumbai Escort Services-
http://www.escortagencyinmumbai.com/
http://www.escortagencyinmumbai.com/
 

My Name Is Priya Singh. I Am An Independent Mumbai Escort Girl. I Run My Own Mumbai Escorts In Andheri West. You Can Enjoy To My Private Parts At Your Own Place. Being A Professional Escort Girl I Have Seven Years’ Experience Of Mumbai Escorts. Hence I Understand And Feel The Real Needs And Requirement Of My Each Client. According The Convenience You Can Avail My VIP Escort Service At Your Home Or In Hotel Also. 
To Book My VIP Mumbai Escort Service Call +91 9987215552.     Visit     http://www.escortagencyinmumbai.com/
 
Visit The Links Below And Have A Look At My Various Mumbai Escort Services-
Mumbai Escorts
Escort Service In Mumbai
Mumbai Escorts
 

Ghaziabad is a place where you can hire amazing escort Girls and Russian Call Girls in Ghaziabad truly beautiful and sexy Ghaziabad Call Girls for dating. Ghaziabad Call Girls *** 
Ghaziabad Escorts *** 
Female Escorts Ghaziabad *** 
adarsh nagar Escorts *** 
aerocity Escorts *** 
ahinsa khand Escorts *** 
aiims Escorts *** 
ajmeri gate Escorts *** 
alaknanda Escorts *** 
amar colony Escorts *** 
anand niketan Escorts *** 
anand parbat Escorts *** 
anand vihar Escorts *** 
anaz mundi Escorts *** 
ansari road Escorts *** 
ashok nagar Escorts *** 
ashok vihar Escorts *** 
ashram Escorts *** 
aya nagar Escorts *** 
azad nagar Escorts *** 
azadpur Escorts *** 
badarpur Escorts *** 
bali nagar Escorts *** 
bawana Escorts *** 
bela road Escorts *** 
bhajanpura Escorts *** 
bhogal Escorts *** 
bhorgarh Escorts *** 
bijwasan Escorts *** 
budh vihar Escorts *** 
chanakyapuri Escorts *** 
chand nagar Escorts *** 
chandni chowk Escorts *** 
charmwood village Escorts *** 
chawri bazar Escorts *** 
chhatarpur Escorts *** 
chhawla Escorts *** 
chirag delhi Escorts *** 
chittaranjan park Escorts *** 
civil lines Escorts *** 
connaught place Escorts *** 
crossings republik Escorts *** 
cr park Escorts *** 
dabri Escorts *** 
daryaganj Escorts *** 
defence colony Escorts *** 
dhaula kuan Escorts *** 
dwarka Escorts *** 
east of kailash Escorts *** 
greater kailash Escorts *** 
hauzkhas Escorts *** 
janakpuri Escorts *** 
kapashera Escorts *** 
karolbagh Escorts *** 
lajpat nagar Escorts *** 
mahipalpur Escorts *** 
malviya nagar Escorts *** 
mayur vihar Escorts *** 
mehrauli Escorts *** 
munirka Escorts *** 
nehru place Escorts *** 
paharganj Escorts *** 
pitampura Escorts *** 
rohini Escorts *** 
saket Escorts *** 
south ex Escorts *** 
uttam nagar Escorts *** 
vasant kunj Escorts *** 
vikas puri Escorts *** 
indirapuram Escorts *** 
kaushambi Escorts *** 
raj nagar Escorts *** 
vaishali Escorts *** 
vasundhra Escorts *** 
faridabad Escorts *** 
ghaziabad Escorts *** 
gurgaon Escorts *** 
noida Escorts *** 
greater noida Escorts *** 

I’m planning to start my blog soon, but I’m a little lost on everything. Would you suggest starting with a free platform like WordPress or go for a paid option? There are so many choices out there that I’m completely confused. Any suggestions? Thanks a lot.https://petdustcompcu1981.typepad.com/

<a href="https://petdustcompcu1981.typepad.com//">http://petdustcompcu1981.typepad.com/</a>

Mumbai Russian Escorts , This is one of the essential reasons why these intense and excellent model ladies just as the keen and alluring chicks from our Russian escort Girls in Mumbai, Mumbai have consistently been sought after in light of their hotness which they show. Another surprising element about every one of these Mumbai call model ladies from the Mumbai Russian Escorts, Mumbai is that they have an incredible stamina with regards to meeting extended periods of affection making sessions which our customers love. A portion of the shining consider model ladies in Mumbai that we have with us at our Russian escort benefits in Mumbai, Mumbai are the Hifi Russian escorts, Housewives Russian escorts, College call Girls, Independent Russian escort model ladies, Model call model ladies, Air Hostess Russian escorts, Russian model ladies escorts and a lot more to meet all your sexual wants. These model ladies since being in their prime, won't stop for a second to get inside your jeans immediately once they enter within your lodging or your living arrangement.

<a href="https://royal-escorts.org/escort-callgirls-near-trident-hotel-bandra-kur...">Escorts Trident Bkc ,Hotel Mumbai</a>

<a href="https://royal-escorts.org/escort-callgirls-near-the-westin-mumbai-garden...">Escorts Westin ,Hotel Mumbai</a>

<a href="https://royal-escorts.org/escort-callgirls-near-z-luxury-residences.html">Escorts Z-luxury ,Hotel Mumbai</a>

 

<a href="https://royal-escorts.org/escortsnear-grand-sarovar-premiere.html">Escorts Grand Sarovar ,Hotel Mumbai</a>

<a href="https://royal-escorts.org/escorts-hotel-orchid-mumbai.html">Escorts Orchid ,Hotel Mumbai</a>

<a href="https://royal-escorts.org/female-escorts-near-itc-maratha.html">Escorts ITC Maratha,Hotel Mumbai</a>

 

<a href="https://royal-escorts.org/escorts-near-sun-n-sand-hotel-in-juhu.html">Escorts Sun-n-Sand, Juhu,Hotel Mumbai</a>

<a href="https://royal-escorts.org/escorts-service-near-hotel-leela-mumbai.html">Escorts Leela ,Hotel Mumbai</a>

<a href="https://royal-escorts.org/escorts-near-hotel-ramada-in-powai.html">Escorts Ramada Powai ,Hotel Mumbai</a>

 

 

Mumbai Model Escorts

  1. escorts ITC Maratha Hotel Mumbai
  2. escorts Trident BKC Hotel Mumbai
  3. escorts LA Lit Hotel Mumbai
  4. escorts TAj Land Ends Hotel Mumbai
  5. escorts Sun N Sand Hotel Mumbai
  6. escorts Hilton Hotel Mumbai
  7. escorts Hyatt Hotel Mumbai
  8. escorts ITC Grand Hotel Mumbai
  9. escorts Sea Princess Hotel Mumbai

 

Mumbai Model Escorts

Mumbai Model Escorts

  1. escorts ITC Maratha Hotel Mumbai
  2. escorts Trident BKC Hotel Mumbai
  3. escorts LA Lit Hotel Mumbai
  4. escorts TAj Land Ends Hotel Mumbai
  5. escorts Sun N Sand Hotel Mumbai
  6. escorts Hilton Hotel Mumbai
  7. escorts Hyatt Hotel Mumbai
  8. escorts ITC Grand Hotel Mumbai
  9. escorts Sea Princess Hotel Mumbai

 

Mumbai Hotel Escorts Says: 

You Can Find Escort Service Near by 

  1. escort service near hotel ITC Maratha Mumbai
  2. escort service near hotel Triden BKC Mumbai
  3. escort service near hotel LaLit Mumbai
  4. escort service near hotel Taj Land Ends Mumbai
  5. escort service near hotel Sun And Sand Mumbai

mumbai hotel escorts,

hotel with escort service,

mumbai hotel escort,

escort service hotel,

hotels with escort service,

guest friendly hotels in mumbai,

hotel escort service,

escort service in hotel,

escort hotel,

girl friendly hotels in mumbai,

hotel escort,

royal escorts,

 

Mumbai Hotel Escorts Says: 

You Can Find Escort Service Near by 

  1. escort service near Hilton hotel Mumbai
  2. escort service near Hyatt hotel Mumbai
  3. escort service near ITC Grand hotel Mumbai
  4. escort service near Sea Princess hotel Mumbai
  5. escort service near Four Seasons hotel Mumbai

hotel with escort service,

mumbai hotel escort,

escort service hotel,

hotels with escort service,

guest friendly hotels in mumbai,

hotel escort service,

escort service in hotel,

escort hotel,

girl friendly hotels in mumbai,

hotel escort,

royal escorts,

 

Mumbai Hotel Escorts Says: 

You Can Find Escort Service Near by 

  1. escort service near ST. Regis hotel Mumbai
  2. escort service near Grand Sarovar hotel Mumbai
  3. escort service near Water Stone hotel Mumbai
  4. escort service near Ramada Powai hotel Mumbai
  5. escort service near Trident Narima point hotel Mumbai

hotels with escort service,

guest friendly hotels in mumbai,

hotel escort service,

escort service in hotel,

escort hotel,

girl friendly hotels in mumbai,

hotel escort,

royal escorts,

 

Mumbai Hotel Escorts Says: 

You Can Find Escort Service Near by 

  1. escort service near ST. Regis hotel Mumbai
  2. escort service near Grand Sarovar hotel Mumbai
  3. escort service near Water Stone hotel Mumbai
  4. escort service near Ramada Powai hotel Mumbai
  5. escort service near Trident Narima point hotel Mumbai

hotels with escort service,

guest friendly hotels in mumbai,

hotel escort service,

escort service in hotel,

escort hotel,

girl friendly hotels in mumbai,

hotel escort,

royal escorts,

 

Mumbai Hotel Escorts Says: 

You Can Find Escort Service Near by 

  1. escort service near ST. Regis hotel Mumbai
  2. escort service near Grand Sarovar hotel Mumbai
  3. escort service near Water Stone hotel Mumbai
  4. escort service near Ramada Powai hotel Mumbai
  5. escort service near Trident Narima point hotel Mumbai

hotels with escort service,

guest friendly hotels in mumbai,

hotel escort service,

escort service in hotel,

escort hotel,

girl friendly hotels in mumbai,

hotel escort,

royal escorts,

 

Mumbai Hotel Escorts Says: 

You Can Find Escort Service Near by 

  1. escort service near ST. Regis hotel Mumbai
  2. escort service near Grand Sarovar hotel Mumbai
  3. escort service near Water Stone hotel Mumbai
  4. escort service near Ramada Powai hotel Mumbai
  5. escort service near Trident Narima point hotel Mumbai

hotels with escort service,

guest friendly hotels in mumbai,

hotel escort service,

escort service in hotel,

escort hotel,

girl friendly hotels in mumbai,

hotel escort,

royal escorts,

 

www.royal-escorts.org

Appreciation for really being thoughtful and also for deciding on certain marvelous guides most people really want to be aware of.

http://situsjudicasinosbobet.net/

http://idnplaypokerr.net/

http://bandaronlinepoker.net/

http://poker-places.net/

http://bandarcasinoterbaik.net/

 

 

All the details are in this post is very interesting and brilliant and I am glad to see this post. Gurgaon Call GirlsCall Girls in GurgaonGurgaon EscortsEscorts in GurgaonCall Girls in Gurgaon

All the details are in this post is very interesting and brilliant and I am glad to see this post. Bhiwadi Escorts serviceEscorts service in ManesarGurgaon Escorts service

This buy marijuana stocks online damage appears along with the higher occurrence of genetic impairments, reduced childbirth body weights and untimely splittings up amongst children of ladies that smoke.
 

Oracle Human Resources Management System (HRMS) is a major component of the Oracle E-Business Suite of applications. Oracle fusion financials training is an integrated suite of applications that supports all aspects of the HR function.
 

Always great to see excellent post. Like I mentioned before we see many people get very bad returns from their insurance claims. If you need to hired a Public Adjuster to help you with a new claim or review a recently paid check us out <a href=“https://publicadjustermiamifl.com“>Public Adjuster Miami</a>

p.p1 {margin: 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px; line-height: 14.0px; font: 14.0px Arial; color: #000000}
span.s1 {font-kerning: none}
span.s2 {text-decoration: underline ; font-kerning: none}

No doubt this is an excellent post I got a lot of knowledge after reading good luck. Theme of blog is excellent there is almost everything to read, Brilliant post. 
192.168 l 254
192.168.0.1

It’s a shame you don’t have a donate button! I’d certainly donate to this brilliant blog! I suppose for now I’ll settle for book-marking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to fresh updates and will talk about this blog with my Facebook group. Chat soon!

<a href="http://www.bandarcasinoterbaik.org/">http://www.bandarcasinoterbaik.org/</a>

<a href="http://oaussieonlinecasinoplay.com/">http://oaussieonlinecasinoplay.com/</a>

<a href="http://www.mainlivepoker.org/">http://www.mainlivepoker.org/</a>

<a href="http://www.online-casinos-portal.info/">http://www.online-casinos-portal.info/</a>

Book with us at very reasonable charges. Russian call girls in Lucknow

If you are looking for the music production courses in Delhi then come to musicology for the best music learning.

Pages