You are here
Every person, from homeowner to lawyer, represents a unique perspective. As a board member, each perspective demands unique attention and can push you in different directions. In this series, we will examine some common issues facing HOAs, identify a variety of important perspectives, and use information from industry experts to offer a comprehensive view.
“The tree which moves some to tears of joy is in the eyes of others only a green thing that stands in the way. Some see nature all ridicule and deformity... and some scarce see nature at all. But to the eyes of the man of imagination, nature is imagination itself.” - William Blake
“Seriously, did that squirrel just jump on my roof again from my neighbor's tree that needs to be pruned? I'll be pulling out my shears tomrw" - Somebody on Twitter
What is a tree to you? To your neighbors? Trees can represent beauty and shade, increased property values, maintenance expense, nuisance, and liability. Where you see beauty, your neighbor may see only a mess in the yard, a raised sidewalk, or a damaged roof. How do you respond to the challenge to see problems through all eyes: to recognize different needs, and to respond objectively?
California has (mercifully) dodged the polar vortex engulfing the East Coast, but the winter season can still cause difficult times for associations with large trees. While trees provide aesthetic value to a landscape, they can also cause disputes between neighbors, and demand a great deal of planning, maintenance, and care. Issues of legality and liability seem to arise most often during the winter – a time when storms and natural disasters can cause trees to fall over and injure residents or destroy property. Here we summarize the most common tree-related issues faced by HOA boards: tree planning, maintenance and liability.
Treescape Planning
Elizabeth Lanham, Certified Arborist for Serpico Landscaping, believes that deliberate and organized tree planning is the key to producing an attractive and safe landscape. Indeed, planting trees in the wrong place can lead to unanticipated consequences. A tree planted near concrete, for example, can create safety hazards and maintenance issues if its roots displace the sidewalk or street. The key to tree planning is to research and understand different types of trees before embarking on landscape renovation. In her article, “Happy Trees, Happy Homeowners,” Lanham has outlined a few things to consider when planning your treescape:
- What is the potential size of the tree and its roots once it is full grown?
- Is the tree fruit-bearing? If so, will it be planted in an area that will not create a nuisance when fruit drops?
- Are trees planted a safe distance from power lines and underground utilities?
- Are the trees native and/or appropriate for the type of climate in which you live?
- It may be helpful to hire an ISA-Certified Arborist to help select the right trees and inspect the trees before installation to ensure that you are planting good quality nursery stock.
Maintenance
Trees provide beauty and shade during the summer, but can become a liability when natural disasters strike. Having a landscape maintenance strategy is especially important for the winter season, given the possibility of stormy weather and safety issues. Robert Booty, Principal Consultant for Arborist OnSite, answers frequently asked questions regarding tree failure and discusses maintenance tips in his article, “Can You Sleep on a Stormy Night?”
Some of his suggestions include:
- Have trees inspected by a qualified and knowledgeable professional, such as an ISA-Certified Arborist.
- Ensure that all trees are properly pruned and/or thinned.
- Check for cavities and fungal growth on tree trunks, which may indicate decay.
Legal Issues
In order to avoid liability and damage, HOA attorney Tom Fier advises that boards become familiar with local and state laws regarding tree planting. Further, Fier recommends that the board assigns responsibility for maintenance of trees and landscaping. As it relates to trees, the California Civil Code Section 3346 outlines ownership and damages for injury, and describes what factors constitute a nuisance. In his article "Trees," Fier outlines the most common legal issues among HOAs regarding trees: removal, view and/or privacy issues, overplanting, and cost as it relates to maintenance and planning. As a means of preventing further liability, Fier recommends hiring a tree expert prior to making any changes to pre-existing landscaping.
Whether you are dealing with current tree problems or just planning ahead, try to keep each of the perspectives above in mind. These tips above can enhance property values, and help your HOA reduce the risk of tree-related injuries and potential lawsuits.
- tcoffin's blog
- Log in or register to post comments
Comments
Board Members Talking to vendors
As a board member, I would love to be able to ask vendors questions about "proposed" or "planned" work that I as a board member need knowledge about to determine if the work can be done, should be done and if so how the work should be done. The Property Manager tells me that I can not talk to vendors (those without a contract with the Association) for informational purpose. Board members being treated like mushrooms (kept in the dark, and feed one side views of the PM) and then asked to vote on a contract at at regular Board meeting is so against what I feel a board member should be doing.
Advise me how I can go about gathering information on future projects. I know not to offer contracts, even mention there might be one, so what is the problem here.
Earl Maple, Board Member, Greystone Landing, Huntington Beach, CA
Solar Panel "Boiler Plate" language for CC&Rs
Solar panel policy was discussed at a recent HOA meeting. It is my understanding legal counsel must provide the language which is incorporated into the CC&Rs. Is this true? I have been advised that there is "boiler plate" language which can be used without going through an attorney. Is this true & if so where can it be found?
Very interesting
lawn mowing glendale www.glendalelawnpros.com interesting for gardeners indeed
Board Members Talking to Vendors - reply 10-18-2014
My understanding of the fiduciary duties of a Board member suggests they protect the HOAs rights, avoid doing harm, and maintain legally required pivacy rights.
I certainly don't know it all, and have not read it all either, but I would be very disappointed to find there is any legal basis preventing anyone including a Board member from educating themself about matters their HOA is or may need to address by hiring a contractor. In fact, though the Davis-Stirling Act provides guidance allowing a Board to pay for professional advice, and education, I have not read anything that suggests it prevents an individual Director from speaking with vendors (if there were an ongoing legal dispute with a vendor, that would seem a reason to not speak at least about the subject of the dispute). Disclosure: my ideas are not legal advise, and I am not a lawyer.
It is possiblle that a Property Mgr. is a control freak, or had previous bad experiences, and also wants to avoid too many points of contact. The easy solution is to invite vendors to address the whole Board so they can all get the benefit of learning together. However, for a Board member to speak with a vendor who is not contracted to the HOA (without revealing any proprietary info) is not much different from doing any other form of research.
It's as crazy as the idea that a director should not have the right to cast a disenting vote! Consensus means we all agreed to go along wether we like the decision or not. Fiduciary duty means even if you voted NO, when over ruled, you must now publicly work to make that policy work, rather than to under-mine it. Big difference.
Youre so cool!…the next time
Youre so cool!…the next time I read a blog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as much as this one. brain games for adults
mozilla firefox free download
mozilla firefox free download latest version can move easily download between devices and open your files from www firefox com download free and pick up right.
chibi
Your article has made me experience and deeply impressed, I hope you will have more interesting articles in the near future to share with readers. the impossible quiz
RE:
The connection between these services and spatial criteria is set in graphs and changed into spatial plan standards for urban trees and woods. At that point, new ideas for timberland setups are created and Dissertation proposal service will be connected in the structure of a treescape for contextual study areas.
More involved than I thought
I didn't realize how much get's involved in cutting down a tree. It's about as bad as getting a Sacramento family lawyer to help with divorces and not just want your money.
So what gives? Is cheating a
So what gives? Is cheating a a learned trade, or an inherited vice? One hypothesis goes back to the same old evolutionary argument: men want quantity, women want quality.
https://blog.loveawake.com/2018/08/13/fiancee-visa-philippines-k1-visa-k3-visa/
its quality
Engineering as a subject combines mathematics, logic and science to find solutions to our daily life problems. Over the last few decades, engineering as a profession has seen vast expansion.
top engineering college
top MBA college in chandigarh
mechanical engineering college in chandigarh
Private management college in punjab
college with best placement in punjab
Good content
سيارات اطفال حقيقية كهربائية
سيتمكن أطفال من قيادة ألعاب السيارات بطريقة حقيقية مثل ما نشاهده في الحياة العادية عندما يهمون الكبار في الركوب في سياراتهم والتوجه للعمل، هكذا سيتقمص صغيرك دور السائق الحقيقي وتدريجيا سيزيد طموحه. أيضا من بين ألعاب الأطفال المحببة كثيرا هي السيارات الصغيرة التي تتوفر على عجلات حقيقية مع قدرة عالية في التحكم والتوجيه تعطيها الفرصة في التحرك على الطريق العام بكل سرعة مطلوبة.
دائما ما نتكلم في مدونة السيارات الكهربائية حول أفضل ألعاب الأطفال المتحرك، يمكنكم معرفة كل صغيرة وكبيرة حول ألعاب الأطفال الحقيقية هذه. هذه السيارات تتوفر على ألوان عديدة مع خصائص وإضافات جديدة كليا.
السيارات الصغيرة التي نتطرق اليها جميعها تتحرك ببطاريات كهربائية ستتمكنون من شحنها من جديد وكأنكم تزودونها بالوقود.
Proof of Process Changes
<a href="http://www.carpetcleaningbismarck.com/">Carpet Repair</a>
These laws are crazy. I guess it is what it is though. Thank you
One of the finest sites I've
One of the finest sites I've seen in a while. mspstarcoins.club
Claiming business
http://www.poolservicebakersfield.net
This is nuts. I wouldnt want to be caught in the middle of this
RE: Secure Message from ray.mark.cortez@uhc.com
http://www.poolservicestemecula@gmail.com
All around some trees. THe law is a crazt thing.
Our academic pursuits, along
Our academic pursuits, along with a range of extracurricular activities, help in honing a child's skills and ensuring that he/she grows to be a mature and responsible citizen.
top cbse school in greater noida
Wishing you
Our journey started as frontrunner to bring Apple technology to the Indian subcontinent. Today, SRSG has emerged as one of the leading
full-service player offering an array of products and services for system integration, broadcast consultancy, IT infrastructure
services, maintenance services and digital archiving services for the broadcast industry.
apple reseller in ahmedabad
ipad service center in Delhi
newsroom automation
MacBook pro reseller in delhi
ipad service center Kolkata
audio mixers dealers in ndia
muneer
Sign in to Goodreads to learn more about Httpmarketing and how to contact this company or order those seo book: Author: Mathé Hoogeboom the seo expert and authority about online marketing and search engine optimization ( On page seo / Of page seo ). Goodreads httpmarketing
Very interesting
Gardener very interesting article www.bakersfieldlawnpros.com
Trees
Trees can definitely be an issue in many areas.. budgeting for their care, removal and trimming as well. Here in San Antonio we also come across this issue and some trees on our property as tall as columns sadly had to come down.
Trees
Trees can overgrow and cause a mess with leaves all over our lawn. We do lawn mowing Burbank CA so we see a lot www.burbanklawnpros.com
Congratulations to the
Congratulations to the winners!
free gift codes generator and free gift cards generator and
free gift codes generator and online video downloader and buy high quality backlink and
We offer calculated
We offer calculated visibility for the design and development of technology platforms through ourintensive research-based approach, consistency in performance, and adept decision-making caliber.
website design company in malaysia
online digital marketing in malaysia
Search engine optimization companies in malaysia
Tree
You done a great job because tree and small plants enhance the beauty of the house. It is also effective for the envorment. I have a small garden and i look after it daily.
Root Protection
Nice
Really informative, Your articles were very nice and full of information. Good Job And continue to make useful articles. www.powerfactorsaver.gr
Great Article
I can't believe all the value I got out of this post! Thank you...
I’m just always astounded
I’m just always astounded concerning the remarkable things served by you. Some four facts on this page are undeniably the most effective I’ve had. candy crush
run 3
The information you share is very useful. It is closely related to my work and has helped me grow. Thank you!
<a href="https://run3ds.com/">run 3</a>
I just added this web site to
I just added this web site to my feed reader, excellent stuff. https://www.maidserviceoforlando.com/lakemary
First-class news it is really
First-class news it is really. Maid Service of Lake Mary
넷마블 먹튀
You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work. 넷마블 먹튀
I'm definitely going to
I'm definitely going to bookmark your blog, I just love your post, thanks for such a nice sharing..Hope to get some info on your blog in future. tree trimming