ECHO Supports HOA Claims in Architectural Lawsuit

You are here

On July 3, 2014, the California Supreme Court announced its long-awaited decision in Beacon Residential Community Association v. Skidmore, Owings & Merrill, et al. In a first-of-its-kind ruling, the Court held unanimously that principal architects of new residential construction can be liable to the eventual purchasers of those projects (and their associations) for negligence in performing design services, even where they do not actually build the project or exercise ultimate control over construction.   And ECHO – which filed an amicus curiae (or “friend of the court”) brief on behalf of the Beacon Association – was instrumental in guiding the Court to announce that rule.

The Beacon Project  

The Beacon ProjectThe Beacon Project

The Beacon is a 595-unit, twin-towered development in San Francisco across from AT&T Park.  Its homeowners association, the Beacon Residential Community Association, brought a construction defect action against several parties involved in the construction including two architectural firms.  The Beacon Association alleged that negligent architectural design work by these firms resulted in a series of defects including structural cracks, inadequate fire separations and water intrusion.  But a principal problem had to do with the windows and ventilation.  The Beacon Association alleged that because of the architects’ design errors, units heated up in periods of sun exposure and did not cool down, even at night, because of the concrete and steel construction and resulting “thermal memory” and because there was no way for the heat to escape.  This rendered the units inhabitable and unsafe due to high temperatures.

Earlier Proceedings

In late 2011, the architectural firms filed a motion asking to be dismissed from the lawsuit, claiming that they had “no control” over the ultimate construction of the project and only made “design recommendations.”  Therefore, they concluded, they had no duty to the owners or the Beacon Association.  The trial court agreed, ruling that the architects owed no duty of care to the Beacon Association or its members.  It held that nothing in the complaint alleged that the architects “went beyond the typical role of the architect, which is to make recommendations” to the developer-owner.  Even if the architect designed the buildings, provided construction administration services, and initiated changes and substitutions that contributed to the defects, “so long as the final decision rested with the owner, there is no duty owed by the architect to the future condominium owners ….”  Thus, according to the Superior Court judge, the owners and Beacon Association could not bring a negligence claim against the architects.

In December of 2012, the First District Court of Appeal unanimously reversed the decision of the trial court.  It held that both under the common law and under the provisions of SB 800 (Civil Code sections 895 et seq.), the architects owed a duty of care to the owners and their association.  (ECHO also filed an amicus curiae brief on behalf of the Beacon Association in that proceeding.)

The Supreme Court Decision and ECHO’s Amicus Brief

In its amicus curiae brief, ECHO’s goal was to remind the Court that new home purchasers were ordinary consumers who depended upon tort law to protect them from the consequences of design defects because they had no other reasonable means of protecting themselves. As such, it was sound public policy to impose a duty of care on the architects, benefitting these owners, to perform their design professional services with due care.

First, ECHO pointed to the decades-old understanding that purchasers of new construction were ordinary consumers.  They typically lacked construction expertise of any kind, much less the specialized knowledge of an architect or engineer.  They depended upon those professionals to do their job with the proper skill.   And unlike the developer of a project – or even the more sophisticated owners of commercial properties – residential purchasers could not protect themselves through contracts with either the developer or the design professional (since those were typically signed years before purchasers even visit the project).

Read about the common problems HOAs face with contracts

The architects argued that potential purchasers had the right to inspect the homes before purchasing and, as a result, would have obtained more than an “ordinary consumer’s” knowledge about the conditions of the property.  But ECHO contended that these inspections were not architectural or engineering reviews – nor did the Legislature intend them to be.   They were visual inspections only.  And purchasers did not typically hire architects or engineers as part of a home purchase process.  Additionally, in a condominium association like the Beacon, the owners also owned undivided interests in the common areas, and it was in the common areas where construction defects typically caused the most damage.  Thus – taking the Beacon as an example – a potential purchaser would have to not only inspect the unit, but all of the common area, in order to have specialized knowledge about the defects.

The Supreme Court agreed with ECHO, noting that was “unrealistic to expect homebuyers” to take such measures.  Said the Court:  “A liability rule that places the onus on homebuyers to employ their own architects to fully investigate the structure and design of each home they might be interested in purchasing does not seem more efficient than a rule that makes architects who designed the homes directly responsible to homebuyers for exercising due care in the first place.”

Next, the architects pointed to a provision in their contract with the developer that expressly stated that they would not be liable to the eventual purchasers or any homeowners association.  In other words, the provision specifically stated that purchasers and the association could not be third-party beneficiaries of the contract between the architects and the developer.  And they argued that imposing a duty on them might cause a conflict between their duty to the ultimate purchasers of the units and the contractual duties imposed upon them in their agreement with the owner-developer.

But as ECHO pointed out in its brief, a “party need not be a third-party beneficiary in order for the contracting parties to intend to affect it.”  Moreover, ECHO submitted that an architect’s duty under its contract with the developer was the same as its duty of care to the owners:  to perform its services with reasonable care.  Finally, ECHO countered the architects’ claim that they should be absolved of any duty of care to the purchasers because the developer allegedly concealed the defects.  ECHO showed that this argument went to two different elements of a negligence action – causation and damages – which were not considered until after a duty of care was established.  The Court agreed, holding that such a claim did not “diminish the closeness of the connection” between the conduct of the architects and the injury to the purchasers and the Beacon Association for purposes of determining whether the architects owed a duty of care. It then rejected – as “patently inconsistent with public policy”– the architects’ argument that their duty to the owner-developer would somehow differ from their duty to the purchasers.

Ultimately, the Court concluded that its decision, which built on “substantial case law and the common law principles on which it is based,” was also sound public policy.  It put the onus on the architects to perform their services properly and held them to a duty of care as to individuals and associations who would eventually live in and manage the properties that those architects designed.  Thus, it unanimously affirmed the Court of Appeal’s decision to reverse the trial court’s ruling.  As a result, the architects are back in the case as defendants, and the case can now go to trial.

The Impact of Beacon

While the Beacon ruling repeatedly references architects, there is little doubt that its ruling also applies to other design professionals such as engineers (provided that they are the principal entities providing their services and are not subordinate to another design professional).  Groups advocating on behalf of architects and design professionals claim that this decision is a “sea of change in the law” which will make it more difficult for design professionals to build new projects and obtain insurance.  They are wrong.  As the opinion makes clear, the Beacon holding only affirms the long-standing rule that architects and design professionals are liable to the eventual owners when their defective work causes damage.  It seems clear that this unanimous Court did not believe that it was announcing a fundamental change in the law, but rather finally confirming at the highest level what many lower courts had already concluded.  And practically speaking, insurance companies for architects have been defending and resolving such claims for decades. 

Ultimately, this duty from an architect to an eventual owner (and association) protects home purchasers as ordinary consumers, since they are entirely foreseeable parties that may be damaged if design professionals fail to use due care in rendering their services.  As a matter of public policy, the rule properly places the burden on these design professionals to meet that standard of care.


Ann Rankin is the founding principal of the Law Offices of Ann Rankin in Oakland, CA and a member of the ECHO Legal Resources Panel.  She is counsel for the Beacon Residential Community Association.

Matt J. Malone is Of Counsel to Ram, Olson, Cereghino & Kopczynski.  He authored the amicus brief on behalf of ECHO. 

Blog Category: 

Comments

I found that site very usefull and this survey is very cirious, I ' ve never seen a blog that demand a survey for this actions, very curious...
Seo agency

Admiring the time and effort you put into your blog and detailed information you offer!..
online marketing solutions

Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely useful info specially the last part I care for such information a lot. I was seeking this certain info for a long time. Thank you and good luck.
Girls Birthday Outfit

Very good points you wrote here..Great stuff...I think you've made some truly interesting points.Keep up the good work.
http://ypick.me

i love reading this article so beautiful!!great job!
customize your own t shirt

This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free.
eyeglasses

I know your expertise on this. I must say we should have an online discussion on this. Writing only comments will close the discussion straight away! And will restrict the benefits from this information.
go to my site

Great write-up, I am a big believer in commenting on blogs to inform the blog writers know that they’ve added something worthwhile to the world wide web!..
lifestyle blog

Nice post mate, keep up the great work, just shared this with my friendz
hualien city

Thanks for your insight for your fantastic posting. I’m glad I have taken the time to see this.
t shirt maker site

Green juices are made with fruits and vegetables filled with antioxidants, phytochemicals, minerals and vitamins online video downloader

First You got a great blog .I will be interested in more similar topics. i see you got really very useful topics, i will be always checking your blog thanks. wedding DJ Melbourne

I truly awed after read this in light of some quality work and educational contemplations . I just wanna express profound gratitude for the essayist and want you to enjoy all that life has to offer for coming!. full time jobs near me

Great articles and great layout. Your blog post deserves all of the positive feedback it’s been getting.
layasa hat

One present why galore businesses opt for postcards is because they are overmuch cheaper to be prefab and this can forbear a lot of expenses on the lengthened run. voyance gratuite en direct

Excellent blog right here! I really enjoyed your article! thank you very much! io games

Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon. Maui photographers

I am unquestionably making the most of your site. You unquestionably have some extraordinary knowledge and incredible stories. how to digitize a logo

Good composed article. It will be steady to any individual who uses it, including me. Continue doing what you are doing – can'r hold up to peruse more posts. voyance discount

You have done a great job. I will definitely dig it and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site. Blog posting sites

 

I've spent ages looking for this on the web. Thank God someone did post it. Thanks.... 

pressure washing Gainesville

Hi! Thanks for the great information you have provided! You have touched on crucuial points!
Karriere per Fernstudium

Excellent and very exciting site. Love to watch. Keep Rocking.
tax controversy lawyer

Regular visits listed here are the easiest method to appreciate your energy, which is why why I am going to the website everyday, searching for new, interesting info. Many, thank you cc dumps

So luck to come across your excellent blog. Your blog brings me a great deal of fun.. Good luck with the site. voyance par telephone pas cher

This is a great article thanks for sharing this informative information. I will visit your blog regularly for some latest post.
summoning ritual challenge

This is a wonderful product, taking into account all the information about it, this type of product that prevents user interest in the site, and you will share more ... good luck.  넷마블 먹튀

Great post, and great website. Thanks for the information!
Tishbi Travel Agency

A simple bookmarking tool that makes it easy to save, organize and share your favorite web pages. Access your bookmarks from any computer, phone or tablet. Listango works on all modern web browsers… 넷마블 먹튀

Wow, this is really interesting reading. I am glad I found this and got to read it. Great job on this content. I like it. netbilling payment gateway

Because of this it will be significantly better which you could suitable studies just before manufacturing. You'll be able to create significantly greater guide that way. 바둑이사이트

Great job for publishing such a beneficial web site. Your web log isn’t only useful but it is additionally really creative too. There tend to be not many people who can certainly write not so simple posts that artistically. Continue the nice writing 파워볼사다리

Effortlessly these pages will likely definitely probably become well-known concerning several sites people, for the careful content or even thoughts. free tour Stockholm

An interesting dialogue is price comment. I feel that it is best to write more on this matter, it may not be a taboo topic however usually individuals are not enough to talk on such topics. To the next. Cheers. domino88

A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work pengeluaran sgp

There are some fascinating closing dates on this article but I don’t know if I see all of them middle to heart. There’s some validity however I’ll take maintain opinion until I look into it further. Good article , thanks and we want extra! Added to FeedBurner as effectively 먹튀다자바

I am curious to find out what blog platform you are using? I’m having some small security problems with my latest website and I would like to find something more secure. Do you have any solutions  카지노사이트

Just pure classic stuff from you here. I have never seen such a brilliantly written article in a long time. I am thankful to you that you produced this! 파워볼사다리

“Sometimes I feel like if you just watch things, just sit still and let the world exist in front of you - sometimes I swear that just for a second time freezes and the world pauses in its tilt. Just for a second. And if you somehow found a way to live in that second, then you would live forever.” 파워볼사다리

Nice article, can you really like to generate some free esehop codes ? Try this new tool, i found online

I am commenting to let youknow what a exceptional experience my wife’s child enjoyed viewing your webblog. She picked up many details, with the inclusion of what it is like to have an amazing giving mindset to make a myriad of people effortlessly have an understanding of a variety of specialized subject matter. You honestly inspired her. Thank you for offering the important, safe, edifying not to mention easy pointers regarding your subject to Evelyn. Thanks, anonymous online

Perfectpiece of work you have done, this websiteis really cool withsuperbinformation. VPN speed

أفكار غرف النوم كثيرة جدا، بالرغم من كثرتها لن تجدوا ما يتناسب مع أذواقكم المختلفة، نحن هنا في صفحتنا وفرنا اليكم أهم ما يجب توفره داخل غرف بنات مع ديكورات جديدة كليا ستحبونها كثيرا. هذه الديكورات تعتمد على الألوان المناسبة كما أنها تتطلب حكمة من أجل أن تتلائم جميعها مع بعضها البعض، يمكن أن نصنفها ضمن الديكورات الرئيسية داخل غرف النوم.

You have done a great job on this article. It’s very readable and highly intelligent. You have even managed to make it understandable and easy to read. You have some real writing talent. Thank you. Beast Downloader

This is exactly equally an excellent content i quite really liked checking. This isn't all the time which i possess potential to work out an issue. https://abovethefloor.net/werner-mt26-vs-little-giant-15426/

You have done a great job on this article. It’s very readable and highly intelligent. You have even managed to make it understandable and easy to read. You have some real writing talent. Thank you.  things to do

The style make an effort to delightful. All of them significant knowledge really are designed choosing massive amount historical past feel. I would like the whole thing notably. 안전놀이터

This is actually beneficial, as with any construction project the architect or site planner needs to be careful with each step in the plan because it then becomes a domino effect.  That's why in my work as a concrete contractors we are extra careful when installing a foundation. 

Thanks a lot for this top notch information. It's quite understandable that some might not be aware but how could they if they dont look for the right information. here is it best archero hack

Some great piece of learnings in this piece; one would wonder at times how the world would have been without the blessing of internet here yet another grateful piece I can replicate on my blog https://eshoptips.com

Pages