East Bay Panel Update - Director Liability

You are here

Two weeks ago, we met with a great group of ECHO members at our East Bay Resource Panel. We were gathered to talk about the recent Parth case and how it affects the personal liability of HOA directors. Ann Marquis-Fisher, chair of the Panel and president of her HOA, invited attorney Mark Wleklinski to speak about the case, and David Stompe to discuss the insurance implications.

Here’s a not-so-brief summary of what we learned (it’s long because it’s important!):

Why You Need to Know Your Documents

Erna Parth was a director on the board of Palm Springs Villas II HOA. Her HOA sued her for decisions that she made while on the board, saying that she had breached her fiduciary duty. Ms. Parth, however, claimed that she should be immune from liability because of the “business judgement rule” and “judicial deference.” Also, the association’s governing documents contained language protecting director decisions.

Both the Business Judgment Rule and the principle of Judicial Deference help to protect board members from personal liability, even when they make bad decisions. So what happened here?

To understand, you need to know something about both terms.

Business Judgment and Judicial Deference

Business Judgement Rule. This rule says that Directors are not personally liable for decisions that result in damage or loss to others, provided their decisions were made in good faith, in a manner which the directors believe to be in the best interests of the corporation, and with such care, including reasonable inquiry, as an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would use under similar circumstances.

In other words, you can’t be personally sued if you put your community first, did your homework, and used common sense.

Judicial Deference. Also called the “business judgment doctrine,” this principle means the courts will defer to business decisions of a board even if a reasonable person would have acted differently. The courts will also assume that directors’ decision are based on sound business judgment. In both circumstances, the suing owner must prove that an association’s decisions do not deserve this deference.

In other words: The courts are going to assume that the association made a reasonable choice, unless the homeowner can prove a specific set of facts.

The Parth Case

But back to Erna Parth. Ms. Parth, claiming to operate with the authority of the board, made a string of questionable decisions. Here are a few:

  • Roofing repairs. Without consulting the board, Ms. Parth hired an unlicensed contractor to make roofing repairs. The board ultimately hired the roofer, but did not see many of the checks (signed only by Ms. Parth) paid to the roofer. The work was later determined to be both overpriced and deficient.
  • Repaving projects and loans. In order to fund a paving project, Ms. Parth signed for loans totaling more than $1.5 million without the approval of the membership as required by the governing documents.
  • Landscaping. Ms. Parth and other board members approved a 5-year landscaping contract in violation of their governing documents.
  • Termination of management. In spite the board’s decision to table the discussion of terminating their management company, Ms. Parth hired a new management company.
  • Security contract. Ms. Parth entered into a security contract on behalf of the association but without approval from the board. The board’s refusal to ratify or pay for this contract ultimately lead to a lawsuit from the security company.

You can visit this site to read the complete details of this case, Palm Springs Villa II HOA vs. Erna Parth.

What Went Wrong?

If bad decisions are protected by law, why weren’t these decisions protected? The court held that:

When courts say that they will not interfere in matters of business judgment, it is presupposed that judgment—reasonable diligence—has in fact been exercised. A director cannot close his eyes to what is going on about him in the conduct of the business of the corporation and have it said that he is exercising business judgment.

In other words, a director must be “reasonably diligent” before the court will apply the business judgment rule or judicial deference. The court also held that language in the governing documents protecting board decisions is subject to the same limits.

Limits on Board Protections

We’re going to assume that ECHO Members are not like Erna Parth. But what does this case mean for you? It means that a board member must show the court that they deserve the protections of the “Business Judgment Rule” and “Judicial Deference.”

You cannot assume that you are protected.

Here are two areas where you need to be particularly careful:

You must know your governing documents. Decisions of the board, even spectacularly bad ones, are usually protected by the Business Judgment Rule. But if those decisions violate the governing documents, the Rule may not apply.

You must investigate and decide. If the board doesn’t investigate a problem, use qualified experts, and fails to make a repair decision, their inaction does not receive judicial deference. In other words, only an investigation and decision qualifies for judicial deference, even if the decision is to do nothing.

A Note about Insurance

Most associations carry Directors & Officers insurance to provide protection against losses (including attorneys’ fees) that result from wrongdoing or negligence. David Stompe highlighted three important points:

  • Always tender to insurance. Insurance companies often deny claims that are not submitted in a timely fashion. If know about a potential claim, it’s important to submit it to insurance promptly.
  • Check your coverage. This may seem obvious, but coverage should be extensive, and should include claims for libel or slander (or other defamation), discrimination, and attorneys’ fees.
  • Check your exclusions. Avoid policies that contain an “insured vs. insured” exclusion.

If you are an ECHO member living in the East Bay and would like to attend these round-table discussions, please check the schedule in the ECHO Journal or online. We’d love to have you! Have a question about our Regional Panels? You can reach us here.


Blog Category: 


I should assert barely that its astounding! The blog is informational also always fabricate amazing entitys. Zonnepanelen plaatsen

I would recommend my profile is important to me, I invite you to discuss this topic. Airco installateurs

Cool you inscribe, the info is really salubrious further fascinating, I'll give you a connect to my scene. Noten bestellen

Initial You got a awesome blog .I determination be involved in plus uniform minutes. i view you got truly very functional matters , i determination be always checking your blog blesss. Tuinaanleg

Thanks for writing such a good article, I stumbled onto your blog and read a few post. I like your style of writing... Amandelen bestellen

Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting?I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style. Thanks a million and please keep up the effective work. Tuinontwerp

This is a good post. This post gives truly quality information. I’m definitely going to look into it. Really very useful tips are provided here. Thank you so much. Keep up the good works. Cashewnoten bestellen

Outstanding article! I want people to know just how good this information is in your article. Your views are much like my own concerning this subject. I will visit daily your blog because I know. It may be very beneficial for me. Tuin ontwerpen

You know your projects stand out of the herd. There is something special about them. It seems to me all of them are really brilliant! Walnoten bestellen

I visit your blog regularly and recommend it to all of those who wanted to enhance their knowledge with ease. The style of writing is excellent and also the content is top-notch. Thanks for that shrewdness you provide the readers! Ontwerp tuin

When you use a genuine service, you will be able to provide instructions, share materials and choose the formatting style. Hazelnoten bestellen

I found this is an informative and interesting post so i think so it is very useful and knowledgeable. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. Paranoten bestellen

This particular is usually apparently essential and moreover outstanding truth along with for sure fair-minded and moreover admittedly useful My business is looking to find in advance designed for this specific useful stuffs… Tuin aanleggen

It's superior, however , check out material at the street address. Pistachenoten bestellen

Your blogs further more each else volume is so entertaining further serviceable It appoints me befall retreat encore. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates. Tuinontwerpen

It is quite beneficial, although think about the facts when it reaches this target. Pecannoten bestellen

I like to recommend exclusively fine plus efficient information and facts, hence notice it: Aanleg tuin

These you will then see the most important thing, the application provides you a website a powerful important internet page: Tuinarchitect

I simply want to tell you that I am new to weblog and definitely liked this blog site. Very likely I’m going to bookmark your blog . You absolutely have wonderful stories. Cheers for sharing with us your blog. Havervlokken bestellen

Want to experiment pleasure and excitement in life? We have the perfect answer to your imagination! Enjoy the warm company of Call Girls in Delhi With Photo and take your senses to a new level of pleasure. When it comes to providing best Delhi girls, Mobile no one does it better than us.

Great post! Really good information
kryger glass

In an era where Biology Writing Services are thriving, it has become increasingly difficult for students to identify with a reliable company that offers Online Biology Writing Services and Biology Essay Writing Services.

Noida escorts have been preferred above all other escorts in the northern part of India Noida call girl have enjoyed the company of their customers and all in all  Noida call girls women in the neighborhood now have a better lifestyle than what they had previously. Independent Noida escorts state some reasons for the change in their lifestyle. delhi escorts One of the primary reasons for this change in the lifestyle is the expansion of the escort industry. Over the last few months delhi call girls has experienced a lot of cultural events that has shaped the neighborhood’s culture. Awareness programs talking about sexual maturity and development have been initiated gurgaon escorts .
gurgaon call girls
ghaziabad escorts
ghaziabad call girl
Faridabad escorts
Faridabad call girls
Delhi call girl


I am Mihika Pal from Bangalore Mg Road, Are you Looking for any Interesting escorts service 

in call and out call Escort girls in Bangalore areas places to choose our stunning escorts agency service here,

To makes you similar as your girlfriend and Housewife get free Whatsapp video chats and dating girls only on Mihika Pal!!

Bangalore escorts

Escorts bangalore

Female escorts Bangalore

Bangalore call girls 

bangalore call girls number

Independent call girls in bangalore


Delhi has experienced the origin of housewives offering their services. Housewife Delhi escorts . I am riya here work as a high profile Call girl in delhi . I am here for last 6 years and have ability of fulfilling every sexual desires of every man. I am truly a self-independent and always ready to enjoy with you. refer to the women who have already been married and stay in the house to perform the household chores. housewives are cunning enough to keep their personal lives hidden under a veil of ignorance and innocence. Noida escorts sexy killer queen I am perfect for you. I am professional in Noida call girls husbands believe that their wives have gone to give coaching to infants or children in school. Faridabad escorts This is pretty unfortunate as the truth is never revealed and the men are none the wiser. gurgaon Call girls
gurgaon Escorts
Ghaziabad call girls
Ghaziabad escorts
Faridabad Call girls
Faridabad Escorts
escorts in delhi

Technology And Services On Arenas
DISH, continues to be focusing aside from TV programming, technology and services on arenas at https://putlocker-online.com/golden-collection. With the launching of dishNET a high-speed Internet service via satellite enlarged their service in 2012. Additionally dishNET provides its clients with an advantage of 1 installation, a single bill, one customer support number plus a discount when bundled together with the most popular TV programming of DISH packages. See more: https://putlocker-online.com/golden-collection/yesmovies

Noida Escorts Well even while seated by a laptop screen on your comfortable bed is not going to Delhi escorts provide you with the comfort you Gurgaon escorts  have been looking forward to, so that all your work-related problems   
ghaziabad escorts right system where you get wonderful, hot and attractive women escorts to satisfy Faridabad escorts all your goals and  you can afford.  And getting something pleased or getting yourself encounter pleased be even if it is a smaller part of their lifestyle or the big boring schedule that appears ahead.
Escorts in delhi 

This is what commonly happens to the newbies in the business industry who do not know how to effectively market their product or service or service. techeglobal.com

delhidating.co.in_72644's picture

Drawing in Excellence Delhi Loves Will Tell About Herself Hello I am the nearest partner of Delhi Loves and I additionally live in Delhi Escorts.  to experience shocking pleasuring associations Delhi Escorts can make your shot transcendent and impact you to regard every depiction of your life. If you have to contribute your noteworthiness with most sweltering young woman around the territory you really need to contact Independent Delhi Escorts.



Contact With Ahmedabad Escorts Girl Manger. Avail Her High Class Ahmedabad Escort Service At Your Home Or In Hotel. Booking 24 X 7 Escorts Ahmedabad Escorts Jamnagar Bhavnagar Escorts gandhinagar Escorts Porbandar Escorts Vadodara Escorts Bhuj Escorts surat Escorts Rajkot Escorts Escorts Ahmedabad Escorts Jaipur

An Ahmedabad escort girl’s duty is to make his client satisfied. And she’ll not just do that by giving erotic pleasure, her aim is also to make the client happy while enjoying pleasure. So you have to ensure that you’ll not just enjoy the erotic pleasure you’ll enjoy it with much more fun and happiness. Escorts Ahmedabad Escorts jaipur Escorts Agra Escorts Lucknow Escorts surat Escorts satellite Escorts SG Highway Escorts Prahlad Nagar Escorts South Bopal Escorts Bodakdev Escorts Mani Nagar Escorts CG Road Escorts Vastrapur Escorts gota Escorts Hebatpur Escorts Isanpur Escorts Sabarmati

If there is one thing which gives fantastic refreshment to both body and soul and helps to restart this busy modern life, then that's entirely an escort only, because the erotic pleasure has that strength which gives happiness and satisfaction that creates an intense enthusiasm. Jaipur Escorts Female Escorts Jaipur Escorts In Jaipur Escorts Jaipur Escorts Mysore Escorts Jaipur Escorts Udaipur Escorts Jaisalmer Escorts Ajmer Escorts Durgapura Escorts Bani park Escorts Jaipur Escorts Lal Kothi Independent Escorts Jaipur

Blue Girl is an Independent escorts in Lucknow with high profile here for your entertainment and fulfill your desires in Lucknow call girls best service. Escorts Lucknow Escorts Delhi Escorts Gandhinagar Escorts Jaipur Escorts Nagpur Escorts Agra Escorts Varanasi Escorts Kolkata Escorts Surat

Hyderabad escorts service offer genuine and top class female escorts in Hyderabad. Book the best russian escorts in Hyderabad with 100 % satisfaction  Hyderabad Escorts Lucknow Escorts Ahmedabad Escorts Goa Escorts Bandlaguda Escorts Hitech city Escorts Chintalkunta Escorts Madhapur Escorts hafeezpet Escorts Escorts Secunderabad Gachibowli Escorts

If you are looking for Jaipur Escorts service or have fun with our independent call girls you're in the right place. Book our cheap girls at a low rate
Escorts Service Jaipur
Escorts Service Ahmedabad
Escorts Service Mahipalpur
Escorts Aerocity
Escorts Ajmeri Gate
Escorts Connaught Place
Escorts Dubai

I would suggest everyone living in UAE or just moved to Dubai must check du home internet packages they do provide an amazing du dongle device so you access to internet all across UAE.

Find out more on Du Wifi Plans

Through our experts, we offer all kinds of Nursing Research Paper Services and Nursing Research Writing Help Services to suit the needs of every student when they are given any Nursing Research Paper Writing Services.


Friends, you have published a very good article on the website, after reading it, I got a lot of information, that's why I will share all my information with my friends. I am a girl who has been working as an independent call girl for 3 years, so I have my client's escort service in Mumbai. If you also want to book a Mumbai Escort Service to spend time with my high profile call girls then we agree to provide you high quality at affordable prices. Can you meet them tonight? 
Andheri Escorts
Vashi Escorts


Select Delhi Girls Delhi escorts agency always ready for you at your doorstep. Beauty Queen provides you high profile independent girl in Delhi top city.

More Info Visit:


Delhi Escorts

Escorts Delhi

Female escorts Delhi

Delhi call girls

Delhi call girls number

Call girls in Delhi

Independent call girls in Delhi

Independent Delhi Escorts


Hi I am hot kiran Providing 24*7 Female Escorts Service in Bangalore at low price.


Mumbai escorts,

escorts Mumbai

Call girls Mumbai

Mumbai Call girls

 If so, then there is no need to worry anymore because in this article we will explain how to opt for a dissertation service that will guarantee your degree. Ultimate Guide to 1337x

Hi, I am Pooja Rai Providing 24*7 Female Escorts Service in Bangalore at a low price. You can book our website given below….
Bangalore escorts
Escorts Bangalore 
Bangalore call girls 
Independent escorts Bangalore